Residents opposed to the proposed Alto high-speed rail project were encouraged to bring copies of unanswered correspondence to Prescott-Russell-Cumberland Member of Parliament (MP) Giovanna Mingarelli’s Hawkesbury constituency office on Tuesday, November 10, as organizers sought to draw attention to what they describe as a lack of communication from elected representatives.

The letter drop was organized by local Alto opponent Kathleen O’Connell Renaud. In a public appeal ahead of the event, the organizers encouraged residents who had previously written to Mingarelli without receiving a response to deliver printed copies of their correspondence to her office at 179 Main Street East in Hawkesbury.

The letter drop was also prompted by concerns about residents’ experiences attempting to return Alto’s permission-to-enter requests to the MP’s office, which O’Connell Renaud said office staff had refused to accept.

She said the lack of communication and proactive engagement from elected representatives had become a significant concern over the previous 10 months, with residents repeatedly requesting public meetings and town halls.

According to O’Connell Renaud, members of the opposition coalition have sent repeated correspondence to Mingarelli, with some receiving no response, generic replies, or assurances of follow-up that never materialized.

Mingarelli disputed the characterization of her office’s responsiveness in written comments provided to The Review.

She said her office had reviewed all incoming and outgoing correspondence related to Alto and had received and responded to approximately 200 communications on the issue.

“All constituents who have contacted my office have received a response,” Mingarelli said, adding that duplicate emails or correspondence do not receive a separate response.

Mingarelli confirmed that one letter was physically delivered to her Hawkesbury constituency office as part of the November 10 initiative, with no other communications related to the activity received either in person or electronically.

She said her office has submitted several ongoing inquiries from constituents to Alto and the federal Minister of Transport’s office and is awaiting responses. Mingarelli added that her office would continue following up on those inquiries.

Among the concerns raised by residents opposed to the project are the business case establishing it as a project of national interest, protections for individuals, farms, the environment, and municipalities, and the potential benefits for communities through which the train would pass without stopping.

O’Connell Renaud questioned why the proposed route could be announced before those concerns had been addressed and why the project was not being considered alongside other transportation options and existing regional transportation challenges.

She said the organizers have asked both Mingarelli and Glengarry-Prescott-Russell Member of Provincial Parliament (MPP) Stéphane Sarrazin to bring residents’ concerns and opposition to the project before their respective legislative bodies, regardless of their own positions on Alto.

“We have asked both MP Mingarelli and MPP Sarrazin to bring not just our concerns but our loud opposition to this project to Parliament and Queen’s Park,” she said.

Mingarelli said she remains committed to listening to residents, ensuring their concerns are heard, and advocating for the community as the project moves forward.

Mingarelli’s response also addressed a request from a local farmer for a visit from the federal Minister of Agriculture to their farm during the summer. She said that, following discussions with the minister’s office, the visit could not be arranged. She added that the minister had visited Prescott-Russell-Cumberland numerous times since the 2025 federal election and was a strong supporter of the local agricultural and business community.

O’Connell Renaud, who was acclaimed to East Hawkesbury Township Council and was sworn in on Monday, November 16, is also a director of ALT-NO, an organization opposing the proposed rail project.