Three Members of Parliament (MP) from other parts of Canada visited the area on Monday, November 16 and learned about the concerns many area farmers and other property owners have about the Alto project and the possibility of the Ottawa to Montréal high-speed rail line crossing local land.
Conservative MP’s John Barlow of Alberta (Foothills), and from Ontario: Dave Epp (Chatham-Kent-Leamington) and Philip Lawrence (Northumberland-Clarke), met with farmers and other residents and also received a tour of areas in East Hawkesbury and Champlain where concerns about the Alto route being constructed are most significant. Their visit concluded with further discussions and lunch at the Vankleek Hill Vineyard.
About 43 people attended the discussion at the Vineyard and they raised concerns about how rail line construction could interrupt farm tile drainage, concerns land could be expropriated without the rail line being constructed, the capacity of the electrical grid to power the trains, and the cost of the project to taxpayers.
The Conservative Party of Canada has stated it is opposed to the Alto project. Barlow said he and other Conservative MP’s will continue their efforts against the plan.
“This is something we are not giving up on,” he said.
Barlow serves as the Vice Chair of the House of Commons Standing Committee on Agriculture and Agri-Food. He said the Liberals have blocked attempts to have Alto discussed at the committee level. He urged residents opposing the project to keep contacting Liberal MPs to show their opposition to the project. Barlow also urged citizens to keep contacting opposition MPs like him, Epp, and Lawrence with their concerns. He said they will help, but the effort must be led by citizens.
Epp, who is also a member of the Agriculture and Agri-Food Committee, said opposition to Alto needs to be made a national concern and relatable to every Canadian.
“There is no business case for it,” he remarked.
Epp added that the Parliamentary Budget Officer (PBO), the independent examiner of federal spending, is planning to undertake further scrutiny of the costs of Alto. The costs were initially projected between $60 and $90 billion, but more recent projections have been as high as $150 billion.
Efforts to question and comment about Alto will continue to be raised by Conservative MPs in the House of Commons, Epp assured the audience.
On Monday afternoon, Epp spoke about his visit to the Vankleek Hill area in the House of Commons. He said residents feel like their Liberal MP’s are not listening.
“These are not just properties on a government map. They are family farms, generational businesses, and livelihoods built over decades,” he told the House.
Epp demanded the Liberal government allow a full study of possible impacts from Alto upon affected communities be allowed to proceed at the committee level.
In a separate conversation with The Review, Lawrence said the lack of communication, both from the federal government and the Alto crown corporation, is creating uncertainty and anxiety among people who may be affected by the project.
“People are fearful, and rightfully so,” Lawrence said.
He added that the lack of answers is only amplifying the fear.
Lawrence is a former member of the House of Commons Committee on Transport, Infrastructure and Communities. The northeastern part of his riding in Trent Hills around Campbellford could also be affected by the Peterborough to Ottawa Alto line.
Cost and a viable business case were also mentioned by Lawrence as two other areas of concern involving the Alto project.
Barlow also cited a lack of transparency and direct communication as factors causing anxiety about Alto for farmers and their businesses. Barlow also remarked that the potential disruption of land and community is greater for farmers in this region because many farms are still operated by generations of the same family which established them.

